I’ve been rather dissatisfied with my laundry detergent lately. I started out using Purex Free and Clear and that was fine, if unremarkable. I tried regular Tide for a while before I switched to the “Seven Signs” Tide (the one in the orange bottle). And that worked fine too. But lately I’ve grown frustrated with stains. I don’t have stink problems, I have STAIN problems. Something is going on with my little ones, Evie mostly, and she is a little poop MACHINE these days. It must be teething. She went from pooping every two days or so to going several times a day, sometimes as often as every couple of hours! Oh the stains!
I know that sunning works wonders but we lack a decent clothesline out in our backyard and with the way the winds pick up in the afternoon around here, diapers have a way of blowing halfway around my yard if I’m not careful. Sunning, for now, is a last resort. I’d love it if I could have a detergent that gets me halfway there and is great at removing stains.
There are things you can do before you even toss a dirty diaper in the pail to help combat stains. For one, using liners helps a LOT. I have a pile of strips of fleece I’ve cut that I lay on top of the fitted soakers. Most of the mess ends up on the fleece (where it easily washes off) and less on the diaper. Another step is to spray the diaper off in the toilet. I admit to being a little lazy about doing this. Sometimes I do, and sometimes I don’t. But spraying off the bulk of the “mess” does wonders. It saturates the diaper so that messes don’t dry onto the fabrics and it removes a good majority of the mess at the same time. Another thing you can do is spray the diaper with Bac-Out or another stain fighting yet diaper solution (a simple search on Diaper Swappers yields a bevy of personal recipes for such things!). This is one thing I would really like to try and will as soon as I have time to sit down and look at my options!
Still… I’ve heard wonderful things about homemade laundry detergents. Looking around on Hyena Cart, you can find dozens of shops that sell homemade detergents to solve all your laundry woes. And a lot of these detergents are not only safe for diapers, but recommended! I’ve put off trying some for a long time, thinking there’s no way they could work as well as my Tide.
I’ve received some samples of WAHM made detergents in several of my orders lately so this last week I tried a few. And.. I’m pretty impressed! Impressed enough that I looked into the different detergents to see if there was one that was recommended above others. I found a great one on Diaper Swappers that comes highly recommended. Her shop there is called “Earthy Products”. I put an order in last week for detergent, pail deodorizer (something we DESPERATELY need these days!) and a dryer sachet that will safely and pleasantly scent the diapers while in the dryer. I’ve heard great things about her products and I can’t wait to try them out! I will be sure to give a good run down here on my experience.
In the meantime, have any of you tried homemade laundry detergent? Either for cloth diapers or for regular laundry? What are your experiences? Share with the class!

I make my own laundry soap with borax, washing soda, and Fels Naptha soap. It works awesome on everything… clothes, diapers, really everything. I use Tea Tree oil and Lavender Oil in the rinse to disinfect and scent my laundry. I don’t even use fabric softener when line-drying. The best part is that for my HE washer/dryer, I only need one tablespoon of the stuff per load. I haven’t done the math, but it is very inexpensive.
I make my own soap with a Dr. Bronners bar, baking soda, and water. I love it, although it does have a slight scent to it, so if you need unscented, it might not work for you. But it does a good job without any chemicals.
I’ve used Rockin’ Green Soap (www.rockingreensoap.com) which is made by Kim of GADBaby.com. AND they come in wonderful yummy scents!
I have used Crunchy Clean and we all Love it!
Makes your CD’s nice, soft and CLEAN!!
Comes in about 50 scents!
I use detergent from Blue bird Bath Company – I love it! It works great on all my laundry.
I use Rockin Green detergent. It comes is wonderful scents like grape soda and fresh linen and all other neat kinds. I get mine at Cutie Poops and Bottoms in Orland Park,IL. But I know they have a website you can order from.
I love Trader Joe’s All Natural Powder Detergent it is super cheap–only 7.99 for 64 loads. I works great even with my hard water. Of course you have to be near a Trader Joe’s to get it.
I started making my own detergent a few months ago and love it for my clothes. They are cleaner than ever!…. diapers however are another story. It seems to have ruined the PUL on my Bum Genius and Tiny Tush! I used a combination of fells naptha, washing soda, and borax. The fells naptha seemed to make them totally unabsorbant while something caused the PUL to break apart and let moisture through. I contacted Cotton Babies and they said that all three of those ingredients really are not good for your diapers. I only washed this way 3 or 4 times….. it’s been rather frustrating. Fortunately there seems to be some kind of a waterproofing spray you can purchase, but I haven’t tried it yet. I’d really caution cloth diaper users that use PUL covers to be careful with the homemade detergents.
I just found a recipe calling for 1 cup borax, 1 cup washing soda & 1 cup baby oxiclean (I saw other versions of the same recipe w/ reg oxiclean though). No soap should keep it from ruining the diapers. I hadn’t noticed mine doing that really, well some had but they’re older so I wasn’t blaming the soap lol. I’m trying out this new recipe now to see how it works.